Taft–Hartley Act of 1947: Truman’s Veto, Union Restrictions and Right-to-Work Laws
Taft–Hartley Act of 1947: Truman’s Veto, Union Restrictions and Right-to-Work Laws
How Congress passed the Taft–Hartley Act over Truman’s veto and what it changed about unions, strikes and collective bargaining.
Quick answer
How Congress passed the Taft–Hartley Act over Truman’s veto and what it changed about unions, strikes and collective bargaining. The National Labor Relations Act of 1935, known as the Wagner Act, had established major protections for union organizing and collective bargaining. During the war and its aftermath, organized labor grew in strength, but major strikes triggered conflict about the balance of rights between workers, unions and employers.
Key facts
On this page
The Wagner Act and organized labor
The National Labor Relations Act of 1935, known as the Wagner Act, had established major protections for union organizing and collective bargaining. During the war and its aftermath, organized labor grew in strength, but major strikes triggered conflict about the balance of rights between workers, unions and employers.
Opponents of existing labor rules argued that unions had acquired excessive power. Supporters defended collective bargaining and warned that new restrictions would undermine workers’ ability to negotiate wages and conditions.
What Congress passed in 1947
Republican majorities in Congress advanced the Labor Management Relations Act, widely called the Taft–Hartley Act after Senator Robert Taft and Representative Fred Hartley. The measure amended, rather than repealed, the basic structure of the Wagner Act.
President Truman vetoed the bill, criticizing its restrictions, but Congress overrode him. It became law on June 23, 1947.
Changes to union conduct
The law identified certain union practices as unfair labor practices, regulating secondary boycotts and aspects of picketing and union pressure. It added requirements relevant to bargaining and union representation.
These provisions were complex and later amended or interpreted by courts and federal labor authorities. Claims about their modern application should distinguish the original 1947 text from later law.
Right-to-work provisions
Section 14(b) permitted states to adopt rules restricting union-security agreements. This provision became central to state right-to-work laws, which generally prevent compulsory union membership or fees as a condition of employment in covered workplaces.
Right-to-work laws do not themselves create a general right to a job. The phrase refers to a particular kind of labor-law rule, not an employment guarantee.
Employer speech and federal remedies
The act included a free-speech provision protecting employers’ expression of views in particular circumstances, provided the speech contained neither threats of reprisal nor promises of benefits. It also changed the organization and functions of the National Labor Relations Board.
These changes reflected a policy of regulating conduct by both management and unions, though supporters and critics disagree about whether the resulting balance was fair.
National emergency strikes
The act enabled the president to seek an injunction during certain labor disputes posing risks to national health or safety, creating a temporary cooling-off period. The mechanism gave the federal government a tool for intervening in major economic disruptions.
This did not abolish all strikes or eliminate collective bargaining. Its effect depends on the specific circumstances and legal process.
Legacy of Taft–Hartley
Taft–Hartley became a durable part of U.S. labor law and a continuing subject of debate among unions, businesses and policymakers. Its passage over a presidential veto also demonstrated the political consequences of the 1946 midterm elections.
The best historical account identifies the original rules, their contemporary critics and the many later changes, rather than treating every present-day labor dispute as a direct effect of 1947.
Frequently asked questions
When did Taft–Hartley become law?
June 23, 1947.
Did Truman support it?
No. He vetoed it, and Congress overrode his veto.
What does Section 14(b) do?
It permits states to restrict certain union-security arrangements.
Sources and further reading
Related history: Wagner Act of 1935 · Employment Act of 1946
