|

Presidential Election of 1948: Truman vs. Dewey, Thurmond and the Upset

POSTWAR HISTORY · November 2, 1948

Presidential Election of 1948: Truman vs. Dewey, Thurmond and the Upset

How Truman defeated Thomas Dewey and Strom Thurmond in the 1948 presidential election, winning 303 electoral votes.

Quick answer

How Truman defeated Thomas Dewey and Strom Thurmond in the 1948 presidential election, winning 303 electoral votes. Harry Truman had become president in April 1945 after Franklin Roosevelt’s death. The end of the war was followed by inflation, labor disputes, housing shortages and disagreements over domestic and foreign policy. Republicans gained control of Congress in 1946, encouraging predictions of a presidential defeat for Truman.

Key facts

WinnerHarry S. Truman
Electoral votesTruman 303, Dewey 189, Thurmond 39
Democratic vice presidentAlben W. Barkley
Republican candidateThomas E. Dewey
On this page
  1. Why Truman appeared vulnerable
  2. A divided Democratic coalition
  3. Truman’s campaign strategy
  4. The election results
  5. The famous newspaper headline
  6. Congress and the second Truman administration
  7. Why 1948 remains historically important
  8. FAQs
  9. Sources

Why Truman appeared vulnerable

Harry Truman had become president in April 1945 after Franklin Roosevelt’s death. The end of the war was followed by inflation, labor disputes, housing shortages and disagreements over domestic and foreign policy. Republicans gained control of Congress in 1946, encouraging predictions of a presidential defeat for Truman.

Thomas E. Dewey, governor of New York and the Republican nominee, entered the campaign with a substantial reputation and considerable confidence among political observers.

A divided Democratic coalition

The Democratic Party fractured in 1948. Southern segregationists opposed Truman’s civil-rights positions and backed Strom Thurmond as the States’ Rights Democratic candidate. A separate Progressive Party ticket under Henry Wallace challenged the administration from a different direction, including over Cold War policy.

These splits mattered because they threatened the coalition on which earlier Democratic electoral victories had depended. They did not, however, divide the national electoral vote evenly among all four candidates.

Truman’s campaign strategy

Truman traveled extensively by rail, addressed crowds around the country and criticized what he called the do-nothing 80th Congress. His messages emphasized farmers, workers and families affected by economic change. Dewey conducted a more measured campaign, frequently avoiding sharp policy commitments.

The contrasting styles helped Truman cast himself as an energetic incumbent rather than a president waiting for defeat.

The election results

On November 2, Truman won 303 electoral votes to Dewey’s 189. Thurmond received 39 electoral votes from four southern states; Wallace won none. Truman also won a plurality of the nationwide popular vote, not an outright majority.

Vote totals differ slightly among historical datasets due to aggregation practices. The Electoral College result, however, is firmly established by official congressional records.

The famous newspaper headline

An early edition of the Chicago Daily Tribune carried the incorrect headline ‘Dewey Defeats Truman’. The image of Truman holding the newspaper became an enduring symbol of mistaken pre-election expectations.

The episode is memorable but should not substitute for an explanation of the voters, regional coalitions and campaign issues that produced the result.

Congress and the second Truman administration

Democrats also regained control of Congress in 1948. Truman’s victory strengthened his mandate to pursue domestic measures later associated with the Fair Deal, although congressional resistance continued.

It also showed that the Democratic coalition could survive a major split, at least for this election. Debates over civil rights and southern realignment continued to reshape party politics over subsequent decades.

Why 1948 remains historically important

The election challenged forecasts, demonstrated the importance of direct campaigning and made civil rights a more visible national party issue. It was not merely a surprise ending to an otherwise predetermined race.

The interaction of economic conditions, candidate strategy, splinter parties and turnout offers a more informative explanation than the mistaken newspaper headline alone.

Frequently asked questions

Who won the 1948 election?

Harry S. Truman.

How many electoral votes did Truman receive?

303.

Who was Strom Thurmond?

The States’ Rights Democratic candidate who received 39 electoral votes.

Sources and further reading

Related history: 1946 Midterm Elections · Executive Order 9981

Similar Posts